So those are both Haley? And, you prefer the “I’m an insecure high school student with sun burned shoulders”, taken with faulty focus and bad lighting to the second, in focus, photo of a self assured woman?
Frankly, both photos have problems but I like the Facebook photo more.
The second shot is boring. The terrible photographer doing yearbook shots can knock that shot out 1000+ times a day. The second shot was going for something different, but it was a bag of fail too, as was previously listed. I like that he was going for something more creative and interesting, but he did not nail it in the camera and the post production to fix it just made it worse IMO.
I think I found one near my area. Normally I wouldn’t really care if they called themselves a “photographer” instead of “Fauxtographer” except when you start hyping how much training and dedication you have and all that other jazz about being a pro. That’s where I draw the line.