Home › Forums › Main YANAP Discussion Forum › "Real" photographers are dumb › Reply To: "Real" photographers are dumb

#8760
stef
Participant

Define good art then? Contemporary art is much more concept-based than about formal things as ”beauty” or composition. Of course in an ideal case the content and form are entwined together. All images are potentially art but not actually.

That’s not really the scope of this website… that’s the scope of formal education. I would agree that nearly all the photos posted here are “interesting”. But “interesting” doesn’t mean “good”. For example, portraits (which you seem to disdain with a “been there, done it, boring”) have very specific aesthetics and intent. If it doesn’t meet that intent, it’s a “bad” portrait even if it’s otherwise interesting. Food photography has a certain intent, and if it looks like really really interesting vomit on a shingle, it’s still bad photography.

What do you care if someone wants to pay for a less educated photographer than you? Is it directly out of your pocket? They will also get paid most likely a lot less. Some people also make a clear decision not to pay 3000 dollars/euros/pounds for wedding photos and rather settle for less quality for a cheaper price just to document the event. And they get what they bargained for.

True, it’s their money, but there is an issue that perhaps an example will make clear.

Doctors work really hard, have a lot of education, and are pretty well paid in general.

What if … there were no regulations on it, and anyone could call themselves an MD? Toss stethoscope around your neck, and boom: instant MD.

 

A couple things would happen. First, it would become very difficult to find a competent MD. It would be a minefield for the hapless sick person. There would be a TON of uncertainty in the field. Even if you got lucky and your doctor was extremely competent, he would be very difficult to trust on the first visit, because you couldn’t be sure of what you were getting.

Second, all the hacks would be charging a lot less due to competition. The competition among the real and fake doctors increased dramatically, but the average competence dropped precipitously. And lower average competence generally means they’ll have to charge lower average prices. People would subsequently see crazy low prices for services. As a result, they would come to expect those prices, even when they’re dealing with a very competent doctor. The competent doctor will definitely be affected by this competition, even if nobody is anywhere as competent as he. And because of this, there would be little incentive to get formal, expensive education to become a doctor. Why pay $100k/year to go to Harvard when you can pay $100 for a diploma from Haarvard?

 

This has already happened with photography. How many people actually are pursuing degrees in it? Now, go ask both of them if it was worth it.