@meganray — Ali may not have asked for a critique but her photo was linked in this thread and it appears from the discussion that she is charging for her time and expertise. If she is taking them and providing them for free, a different standard may be applied.
@sask13 — It seems anyone can call themselves a professional photographer and start charging for their services. It amazes me what some are charging for, and it amazes me even more that they are actually getting paid. Are they able to charge for enough work that they can make a living doing it?
If you like the edited version, you can pick up a copy here.