Home Forums Photography Showcase Critique Reply To: Critique

#17627
IHF
Participant

so you prefer this

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393997414./370652773027768/?type=3&theater

 

over this

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393989217./542779529148424/?type=3&theater

 

This one

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393998487./410415462384832/?type=3&theater

over this one

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393989217./540140072745703/?type=3&theater

 

and this interior shot

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393997316./431418440284534/?type=3&theater

 

over this one

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393989217./540138836079160/?type=3&theater

 

JMO but blurry, noisy, badly color managed and/or converted, badly posed and set up isn’t a “style”.  Looks like “style” wise you are duplicating, but quality wise it’s a toss up. It’s as though your clients are playing the lotto when/if they hire you.

 

Just saying from an outsiders point of view, it looks more like you are trying to emulate/recreate the better shots and not quite achieving it.  I think perhaps you might be compelled to over edit sometimes because the image doesn’t quite cut it (missed focus,low contrast, bad exposure etc), and in an attempt to try to make it better you over do it?

 

There’s not much progression from your very first shot that you shared

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393999421./165427760216938/?type=3&theater

and your newest

https://www.facebook.com/DianaKMillerPhotography/photos/pb.165416636884717.-2207520000.1393999357./597987403627636/?type=3&theater

 

They are both badly focused, noisy, and badly edited.

 

The “progression” strangely seems to happen randomly throughout your port instead. hmmmmmmmm