Reply To: Constructive Criticism

[joe]

The original is so much better.  I disagree with the lighting being bad.  here are no harsh shadows.  There is a shadow under the brim of the hat but it is not harsh.  The Post Processing killed this image in my mind.

I think vignetting is a great tool when use properly.  I use it and you generally cant tell i used it unless you look at the original.  Used properly it helps draw the viewer in.